The Metals’ Family Tree and their Separate Branches: an Experiential Journey
2024, 62, No. 1
Publication date
Publishing model
License type
Field
Discipline
Language of publication
Downloads
PDF 13 MB
Number of views:132
Number of downloads:37
Crossref citations:0
Altmetric score:0
Abstract
Metals have been integral to people’s lives for several millennia. We interact with them daily in many forms to fulfil a wide range of needs, from food preparation or elaboration of attire, to architectural components or means of transportation. We take for granted that one material meets these distinct challenges, but discovering metal’s versatility has only been achievable through long-term engagement over a period of millennia. This enabled craftspeople to learn and understand their special characteristics, or properties, which both facilitate and constrain usage, with each metal having its own unique combination of properties. Due to this, craftspeople frequently employ multiple metals for a single artefact, melding together a desired package of properties. The significant differences between the metals and their recurrent use in combination thus calls for an intra-cross-craft approach. Past metal production can only be fully understood by comprehending these properties. This knowledge comprises elements that can be transmitted discursively, but also those that can only be transmitted non-discursively, the latter being impossible to communicate in full without direct experience, which can be difficult to acquire. This paper proposes methods through which such direct experience of the properties of metals can be obtained, by inviting readers to participate in simple experiential activities using common household items. These properties are then discussed in an intra-cross-craft setting, using case studies to demonstrate how and why different metals are used together and the implications of these technical practices.
Keywords:
Bibliography
Alvarez L. E. 2023, Le Miroir en Égée à l’Âge du Bronze récent. Formes, fonctions, usages et trajectoires entre le XVIe et le XIe siècle, Aegaeum 48, Leuven.
Aulsebrook S. 2022, Forging ahead or foiled again? A new direction for cross-craft analysis with case studies from Late Bronze Age metalworking in the Aegean, in: S. Aulsebrook, K. Żebrowska, A. Ulanowska (eds), Sympozjum Egejskie. Papers in Aegean Archaeology 3, Warsaw Studies in Archaeology 3, Turnhout, 99–112.
Berranger M., Fluzin P. 2012, From raw iron to semi-product: quality and circulation of materials during the Iron Age in France, Archaeometry 54, 664–684.
Betz O. 1995, Considerations on the real and the symbolic value of gold, in: G. Morteni, J. P. Northover (eds), Prehistoric Gold in Europe, Dordrecht, 19–28.
Blackwell N. G. 2018, Experimental stone-cutting with the Mycenaean pendulum saw, Antiquity 92.361, 217–232.
Brady G. S., Clauser H. R., Vaccari J. A. 2002, Materials Handbook: An Encyclopaedia for Managers, Technical Professionals,
Purchasing and Production Managers, Technicians, and Supervisors, Fifteenth Edition, New York.
Budd P., Taylor T. 1995, The faerie smith meets the bronze industry: magic versus science in the interpretation of prehistoric metal-making, World Archaeology 27.1, 133–143.
Cardarelli F. 2018, Materials Handbook. A Concise Desktop Reference, Third Edition, London.
Catling H. W., Jones R. E. 1977, Analysis of copper and bronze artefacts from the Unexplored Mansion, Knossos, Archaeometry 19, 57–66.
Clarke C. F. 2013, The Manufacture of Minoan Metal Vessels: Theory and Practice, Studies in Mediterranean Archaeology Pocket Book Series 178, Uppsala.
Coles J. M. 1962, European Bronze Age shields, Proceedings of the Prehistoric Society 28, 156–190.
DeVries M. F., Thomsen H. H., Thomsen E. G. 1980, The manufacture of an ancient silver bowl, Journal of Applied Metalworking 1, 52–60.
Dolfini A., Crellin R. 2016, Metalwork wear analysis: the loss of innocence, Journal of Archaeological Science 66, 78–87.
Doonan R. C. P., Dungworth D. 2013, Experimental archaeometallurgy in perspective, in: D. Dungworth, R. C. P. Doonan (eds), Accidental and Experimental Archaeometallurgy, London, 1–10.
Evely R. D. G. 1993, Minoan Crafts: Tools and Techniques. An Introduction I, Studies in Mediterranean Archaeology 92.1, Göteborg.
Evely R. D. G. 2000, Minoan Crafts: Tools and Techniques. An Introduction II, Studies in Mediterranean Archaeology 92.2, Jonsered.
Fang J.-L., McDonnell G. 2011, The colour of copper alloys, Historical Metallurgy 45, 52–61.
Fregni E. G. 2014, The Compleat Metalsmith: Craft and Technology in the British Bronze Age, unpublished PhD thesis, University of Sheffield.
Garside P., Richardson E. (eds) 2021, Conservation Science: Heritage Materials, Second Edition, La Vergne.
Hermann R., Crellin R. J., Uckelmann M., Wang Q., Dolfini A. 2020, Bronze Age Combat. An Experimental Approach, British Archaeological Reports International Series 2967, Oxford.
Hinde R. A. 1998, Mind and artefact: a dialectical perspective, in: C. Renfrew, C. Scarre (eds), Cognition and Material Culture. The Archaeology of Symbolic Storage, McDonald Institute Monographs, Cambridge, 175–179.
Hoffman C. 1999, Intentional damage as technological agency: breaking metals in Late Prehistoric Mallorca, Spain, in: M.-A. Dobres, C. Hoffman (eds), The Social Dynamics of Technology. Practice, Politics, and World Views, Washington, D.C., 103–123.
Hughes R. 1993, Artificial patination, in: S. La Niece, P. Craddock (eds), Metal Plating and Patination. Cultural, Technical and Historical Developments, Oxford, 1–18.
Konstantinidi-Syvridi E., Papadimitriou N., Philippa-Touchais A., Goumas A. 2014, Goldworking techniques in Mycenaean Greece (17th/16th–12th century BC): some new observations, in: H. Meller, R. Risch, E. Pernicka (eds), Metalle der Macht – Frühes Gold und Silber: 6. Mitteldeutscher Archäologentag vom 17. bis 19. Oktober 2013 in Halle (Saale). Metals of Power – Early Gold and Silver: 6th Archaeological Conference of Central Germany, October 17–19, 2013 in Halle (Saale), Tagungen des Landesmuseums für Vorgeschichte Halle 11/I, Halle (Saale), 335–348.
Konstantinidi-Syvridi E., Papadimitriou N., Goumas A., Philippa-Touchais A., Prévalet R. 2019, Experimenting on Mycenaean goldworking techniques: the case of the granulated cone, in: C. Souyoudzoglou-Haywood, A. O’Sullivan (eds), Experimental Archaeology: Making, Understanding, Story-telling. Proceedings of a Workshop in Experimental Archaeology: Irish Institute of Hellenic Studies at Athens with UCD Centre for Experimental Archaeology and Material Culture, Dublin, Athens 14th–15th October 2017, Oxford, 43–52.
Konstantinidi-Syvridi E., Papadimitriou N., Goumas A. 2020, Reviving the techniques of the Mycenaean goldsmith, in: M. Panagiotaki, I. Tomazos, F. Papadimitrakopoulos (eds), Cutting-Edge Technologies in Ancient Greece: Materials Science Applied to Trace Ancient Technologies in the Aegean World. Proceedings of Two Conferences Held in Rhodes, 12–14 January 2018 and 11–13 January 2019, Oxford, Philadelphia, 55–61.
Konstantinidi-Syvridi E., Papadimitriou N., Goumas A. 2024, The gold kylikes of the Mycenae acropolis: tracing their technology and origin, in: R. Laffineur, M. Perna (eds), Ίχνη: Walking in the Footsteps of the Pioneer of Aegean Archaeology in Celebration of the 200th Anniversary of the Birth of Heinrich Schliemann. Proceedings of the 19th International Aegean Conference/19e Rencontre égéenne internationale, Centro Internazionale per la Ricerca sulle Civiltà Egee “Pierre Carlier”, Comune di Oristano e Fondazione Oristano, Università degli Studi di Sassari, May 10–14, 2022, Aegaeum 49, Leuven, Liège, 185–198.
Kuijpers M. 2015, The sound of fire, taste of copper, feel of bronze, and colours of the cast: sensory aspects of metalworking technology, in: M. L. S. Sørensen, K. Rebay-Salisbury (eds), Embodied Knowledge: Perspectives on Belief and Technology, Oxford, 137–150.
Kuijpers M. 2018, The Bronze Age, a world of specialists? Metalworking from the perspective of skill and material specialisation, European Journal of Archaeology 21, 550–571.
Maragoudaki E., Kavvouras P. K. 2012, Mycenaean shipwright tool kit: its reconstruction and evaluation, Archaeological and Anthropological Sciences 4, 199–208.
Martin V. 2023, Metal “ring idols”: a material approach to metalworking in the Aegean Neolithic, in: S. Aulsebrook, K. Żebrowska, A. Ulanowska (eds), Sympozjum Egejskie. Papers in Aegean Archaeology 4, Warsaw Studies in Archaeology 5, Turnhout, 13–27.
Mödlinger M., Trebsche P. 2021, Work on the cutting edge: metallographic investigation of Late Bronze Age tools in southeastern Lower Austria, Archaeological and Anthropological Sciences 13, 125 ( accessed 26 October 2024).
https://doi.org/10.1007/s12520-021-01378-1,
Mohamed W., Darweesh S. 2012, Ancient Egyptian black-patinated copper alloys, Archaeometry 54, 175–192.
Nosch M.-L. 2016, Spinning gold and casting textiles, in: J. Driessen (ed.), Ra-pi-ne-u: Studies on the Mycenaean World Offered to Robert Laffineur for His 70th Birthday, Aegis 10, Louvain-la-Neuve, 221–232.
Notis M. R. 2014, Metals, in: B. W. Roberts, C. P. Thornton (eds), Archaeometallurgy in Global Perspective. Methods and Syntheses, New York, 47–66.
Papadimitriou N., Konstantinidi-Syvridi E., Goumas A. 2016, Technological study and interpretation of rhomboid accessories from Grave Circle A, Mycenae, in: J. Driessen (ed.), Ra-pi-ne-u: Studies on the Mycenaean World Offered to Robert Laffineur for His 70th Birthday, Aegis 10, Louvain-la-Neuve, 245–262.
Papadimitriou N., Konstantinidi-Syvridi E., Goumas A. 2021, A demanding gold-working technique attested in Armorican/Wessex and Early Mycenaean funerary contexts, Bulletin de l’Association pour la Promotion des Recherches sur l’Âge du Bronze 19, 26–33.
Pingel V. 1995, Technical aspects of prehistoric gold objects on the basis of material analysis, in: G. Morteni, J. P. Northover (eds), Prehistoric Gold in Europe, Dordrecht, 385–398.
Radivojević M., Roberts B., Marić M., Kuzmanović-Cvetković J., Rehren T. 2021, The Rise of Metallurgy in Eurasia: Evolution, Organisation and Consumption of Early Metal in the Balkans, Oxford.
Renfrew C. 1986, Varna and the emergence of wealth in prehistoric Europe, in: A. Appadurai (ed.), The Social Life of Things. Commodities in Cultural Perspective, Cambridge, 141–168.
Scott D. A. 2012, Ancient Metals: Microstructure and Metallurgy I, Copper and Copper Alloys, Charleston.
Scott D. A. 2013, Ancient Metals: Microstructure and Metallurgy IV, Iron and Steel, Charleston.
Selwyn L. 2004, Metals and Corrosion. A Handbook for the Conservation Professional, Ottawa.
Skeates R., Day J. 2020 (eds), The Routledge Handbook of Sensory Archaeology, London, New York.
Thomas E. 2024, Shining light on Egyptian mirrors: new scientific research into their metallurgy, Journal of Archaeological Science: Reports 58, 104744.
Untracht O. 1968, Metal Techniques for Craftsmen, New York.
Vittori O. 1979, Pliny the Elder on gilding: a new interpretation of his comments, Gold Bulletin 12, 35–39.
Whittaker H. 2008, The role of drinking in religious ritual in the Mycenaean Period, in: L. A. Hitchcock, R. Laffineur, J. Crowley (eds), Dais: The Aegean Feast. Proceedings of the 12th International Aegean Conference/12e Rencontre égéenne internationale, University of Melbourne, Centre for Classics and Archaeology, 25–29 March 2008, Aegaeum 29, Liège, Austin, 89–96.
Other articles from the issue
Introduction – Intra-Cross-Craft Analysis Workshop: Investigating Linkages within Craft Industries
- Greek ArchitectureArchitectural InnovationClay Building MaterialsIntra-Cross-Craft InteractionCross-Craft InteractionAegean PrehistoryGreek Archaeology
Intra-Cross-Craft Interaction and Cross-Craft Interaction in the Architectural Domain from the Bronze Age to Archaic Period in Mainland Greece
- potterclayterracottacoroplastCyprusMarionmouldhandmadecoilwheel
The Coroplast and the Potter: Considerations on Cross-Craft Specialists
Similar publications
Introduction – Intra-Cross-Craft Analysis Workshop: Investigating Linkages within Craft Industries
- Greek ArchitectureArchitectural InnovationClay Building MaterialsIntra-Cross-Craft InteractionCross-Craft InteractionAegean PrehistoryGreek Archaeology
Intra-Cross-Craft Interaction and Cross-Craft Interaction in the Architectural Domain from the Bronze Age to Archaic Period in Mainland Greece
- potterclayterracottacoroplastCyprusMarionmouldhandmadecoilwheel
The Coroplast and the Potter: Considerations on Cross-Craft Specialists